COP TIX QUOTA BARED
By LARRY CELONA and LUKAS I. ALPERT
June 20, 2005 -- Three NYPD sergeants have confirmed
what police brass have denied for years: Ticketing quotas exist.
Testifying at a closed-door union-grievance hearing
last week, the sergeants said cops in the 75th Precinct in Brooklyn
were given a minimum amount of summonses to write in each three-month
quarter — or they would get in trouble with their bosses.
One sergeant even submitted a handwritten note from
the East New York precinct's commanding officer that spelled out
the number of collars, moving violations and quality-of-life summonses
that a cop needed to write to avoid being given a poor performance
assessment, sources told The Post.
The missive, obtained by The Post, states that an
officer with fewer than 35 parking summonses in a quarter would
receive a below-average performance rating.
Officers were also told to make 11 collars and issue
33 moving-violation and 33 quality-of-life summonses.
The precinct's commanding officer, Deputy Chief
Michael Marino, admitted at last week's hearing before a city
arbitrator that he wrote the note but said it was only one of
several types of criteria that he used to assess his officers,
the sources said.
The hearing last week before the city's Office of
Collective Bargaining involved six cops who were transferred from
the precinct allegedly because they didn't come up with enough
summonses and arrests.
Union officials say the sergeants' testimony about
a ticketing quota at the precinct lays bare the department's dirty
little secret: that cops are forced to write ridiculous tickets
to raise more revenue for the city or face the consequences.
"The evidence presented under oath in this
arbitration proves once again what police officers have long lived
with: There are established quotas, and if you don't meet them,
you will be punished," said Patrolmen's Benevolent Association
President Patrick Lynch.
Forcing cops to issue a certain number of tickets
and make a certain number of arrests sends the wrong message,
the union argues.
"Quotas damage the trust between the police
and the public," said PBA board member John Giangrasso. "Conditions
can be addressed without putting a financial burden on the community."
But the department counters that the number of arrests
and summonses is just one way of monitoring an officer's productivity
and does not amount to a quota.
"Police officers have a certain degree of discretion
in taking enforcement actions," an NYPD spokesman said. "Performance
must be taken into account in evaluating them, otherwise conscientious
officer would carry the burden alone."
